david

Corporate money vs the people

The campaign to support Issue 2 has been one of the most opaque campaigns in Ohio election history. In order to circumvent transparency laws and campaign finacne reports, Better Ohio created a Rube Goldberg like non profit system whereby donors could donote to a non profit that didn't have to expose who those donors were, or how much they donated. They they turned right around and donated that secret stash to their campaign.

If you look at their campaign financne reports it shows just one donor "BUILDING A BETTER OHIO INC" making all the contributions. That said, they did, under pressure release a list of who donated money to "BUILDING A BETTER OHIO INC", though not the amounts. In total 46 businesses and 950 individuals gave some amount of money to the BetterOhio campaign.

If that hasn't been unfair enough, a host of other corporate backed entities also provided financial heft to the Governor's campaign to hurt working people. Via PR Watch

Alliance for America’s Future

The Alexandria, Virginia-based Alliance for America’s Future (AFAF) has spent over seven figures in an effort to flood millions of Ohio voters’ mailboxes with fliers encouraging a “yes” vote on Issue 2 to uphold the bill. Heading the AFAF is Mary Cheney, the daughter of former vice president’ Dick Cheney, and Barry Bennert, former chief of staff to Ohio Congresswoman Jen Schmidt (R-2nd District). The Alliance does not disclose its corporate donors.

Ohio is just one of 30 states, including Wisconsin, in which the AFAF has become involved. Their official website offers no information on staff or current projects, but instead offers a single webpage stating the AFAF is “dedicated to educating and advocating sound economic and security policies that will foster growth, prosperity, and peace for America’s future.”

The group's fliers include lines such as “OBAMA wants us to do things HIS WAY? Yes on Issue 2 is our chance to do things OUR WAY,” and “Yes on Issue 2 will get POLITICIANS to do the right thing on spending.”

Dick Armey’s FreedomWorks

FreedomWorks, the D.C.-based group affiliated with the Tea Party and led by Dick Armey, has distributed tens of thousands of door hangers and yard signs in Ohio that read “Yes on Issue 2 & 3.”

FreedomWorks, which is led by people who previously worked for David Koch's "Citizens for a Sound Economy," FreedomWorks' predecessor group, does not disclose its corporate donors, and its leaders are drawn heavily from the leadership of the Republican Party and right-wing operatives. FreedomWorks asserts that it is not affiliated with any Issue 2 or 3 Campaign or Committee.

The FreedomWorks website encourages visitors to download and print available door hangers (pdf) with a promise that “tens of thousands more [are] on the way.” 

The group also created the website YesForJobs.com, which allows Ohioans to download absentee ballots and provides information on where to send them. 

Ohio Liberty Council

The Ohio Liberty Council (OLC), a Tea Party group headed by 12 council board members, has released two television ads in support of Issue 2. The OLC claims group leaders and “private citizens” fund it. President, Tom Zawistowski and Vice President, Jason Mihalick lead the OLC, which does not disclose its donors.

In one OLC ad, the narrator states that Issue 2 is not one of “pro-union” or “anti-union” but rather about “taxpayers rights.”

A second television ad, “The Story of a Broke Ohio,” states that we will be in a deficit because “96 percent of schools tax revenue will go toward staff compensation,” and what they call “Gold-plated pensions and benefits.”

This statistic was pulled from a study by The Buckeye Institute, a conservative 501 (c)(3) “research organization” that has been used in a number of campaigns and as an “expert” on SB5. The Buckeye Institute “study” highlights the projected deficits of nineteen Central Ohio School Districts, and concludes that Central Ohio School Districts will have a budget deficit of nearly $1 billion by 2015 unless compensation packages are realigned or taxes are raised.

The “study” was released as an ad that appeared in twenty-two suburban news weeklies across central Ohio. The ad on its own does not mention SB 5, but it is used in a number of pro SB 5 campaigns.

The “study” places the burden of responsibility for the deficit on government employees, and ignores the fact that Ohio union officials agreed to pay more for insurance and accept wage cuts and freezes.

Americans for Prosperity

The Americans for Prosperity Ohio branch is organizing support for SB 5. AFP Ohio has scheduled more than a dozen town hall meetings across Ohio, organized phone banks and is currently urging supporters of the bill to defend Building a Better Ohio’s “Life or Death” ad featuring great-grandmother Marlene Quinn.

Americans for Prosperity is chaired by oil billionaire David Koch and funded by Koch money and other undisclosed sources. The group includes both a 501(c)(3) that received over $10 million in 2009, and a 501(c)(4) that received over $16 million that year. Neither the national AFP nor its state arms disclose their donors.

Americans for Prosperity’s Ohio branch received a web endorsement from Gov. Kasich in June. In a web-only video, Gov. Kasich praises AFP-Ohio. He refers to the group as “fighters for freedom” and thanks them for their “support to the effort to get Ohio back on track.”

Make Ohio Great

Make Ohio Great is spending thousands to aid Gov. Kasich in his defense of SB 5. Make Ohio Great is a group founded and funded by the Republican Governors Association (RGA), which spent over $9 million to elect Gov. Kasich in 2010. The RGA is funded by billionaires like David Koch and Rupert Murdoch, as well as numerous large corporations. The RGA spent tens of millions on advertisements in the 2010 election year. In August 2010 Rupert Murdoch’s News Corporation donated $1 million to the RGA, along with David Koch and others. Make Ohio Great disputes claims that they are a group set up for secret cash to flow in defense of SB 5.

Make Ohio Great reportedly bought $48,100 in airtime with WBNS-TV.

In the ad, titled “Kasich Getting the Jobs Done,” Kasich asks Ohioans to “take a new path,” and boasts that he has balanced the budget without raising taxes.

Kasich may be speaking too soon, as his economic plan for Ohio depends in part on SB 5 becoming law. The cost-savings come from requiring employees pay more for health insurance, and limiting their vacation and sick time, some of which unions had agreed to voluntarily. Ending collective bargaining, though, saved the state no money -- despite messaging to the contrary by out-of-state right-wing organizations, balanced budgets need not come at the expense of collective bargaining.

SB5 could turn Gov. Kasich into a lame duck

A short while ago we published an analysis piece to determine which of the Senators who voted for SB5 would be up for reelection in 2012. A number of readers asked us to perform the same analysis for those House members who voted for SB5, so here it is.

The Ohio House of Representatives is made up of 99 districts. Currently the Republicans control 59 and the Democrats 40. The House is quite different from the Senate. Representatives are elected every 2 years, not every 4 and every district will be contested in 2012. Representatives become term limited after 4 terms. So with that basic understanding, let’s look at the SB5 roll call.

We can eliminate all of the Democrats from consideration as not a single one of them voted for SB5.

While SB5 was passed on a party line vote, some Republicans did cross the isle to vote no too. They were Randy Gardner (R), Ross W. McGregor (R), John Carey (R), Terry Johnson (R), and Casey Kozlowski (R). That reduces the potential total to 54 Republicans who voted for SB5.

Five of these Representatives will be term limited, they are Louis W. Blessing, Jr. (R), Courtney Combs (R), William P. Coley, II (R), Joseph W. Uecker (R) and Danny R. Bubp (R). So we’re down to 49.

One other Republican who is unlikely to be on the ballot next year is Rep Mecklenborg (R). He was recently arrested for a DUI in Indiana enjoying the company of a young woman purported to be an employee of a nearby adult entertainment establishment. It’s quite possible he won’t serve out his term, as calls for his resignation continue to grow.

That then, gives us 48 potential Republican Representatives who will be on the ballot in 2012 who voted for SB5. They are, sorted by their 2010 votes for percentage:

District Member Percentage vote for Percentage vote against
91 Bill Hayes (R) 47.06 52.94
41 Lynn Slaby (R) 49.9 50.1
21 Mike Duffey (R) 50.48 49.52
96 Al Landis (R) 51.04 48.96
42 Kristina Roegner (R) 51.69 48.31
18 Mike Dovilla (R) 52.41 47.59
1 Craig Newbold (R) 52.58 47.42
19 Anne Gonzales (R) 52.68 47.32
63 Ron Young (R) 53.14 46.86
93 Andy Thompson (R) 53.81 46.19
17 Marlene Anielski (R) 54.75 45.25
43 Todd McKenney (R) 54.99 45.01
81 Rex Damschroder (R) 55.31 44.69
85 Bob Peterson (R) 55.32 44.68
46 Barbara R. Sears (R) 56.34 43.66
86 Cliff Rosenberger (R) 59.46 40.54
16 Nan A. Baker (R) 60.19 39.81
50 Christina Hagan (R) 60.52 39.48
58 Terry Boose (R) 62.29 37.71
36 Michael Henne (R) 63.27 36.73
23 Cheryl L. Grossman (R) 63.41 36.59
34 Peter Stautberg (R) 64.81 35.19
38 Terry Blair (R) 67.49 32.51
98 Richard Hollington (R) 68.44 31.56
97 David Hall (R) 68.8 31.2
74 Bruce W. Goodwin (R) 69.01 30.99
51 Kirk Schuring (R) 69.2 30.8
71 Jay Hottinger (R) 69.31 30.69
84 Bob D. Hackett (R) 69.7 30.3
37 Jim Butler (R) 69.71 30.29
70 Jarrod B. Martin (R) 69.93 30.07
53 Timothy Derickson (R) 70.19 29.81
69 William G. Batchelder (R) 70.34 29.66
2 Andrew Brenner (R) 70.35 29.65
67 Peter Beck (R) 70.74 29.26
76 Robert Sprague (R) 70.78 29.22
75 Lynn R. Wachtmann (R) 72.05 27.95
90 Margaret Ann Ruhl (R) 72.26 27.74
4 Matt Huffman (R) 72.32 27.68
35 Ron Maag (R) 73.02 26.98
78 John Adams (R) 74.27 25.73
79 Richard N. Adams (R) 77.09 22.91
3 Ron Amstutz (R) 100 0
5 Gerald L. Stebelton (R) 100 0
77 Jim Buchy (R) 100 0
82 Jeffrey A. McClain (R) 100 0
83 David E. Burke (R) 100 0
94 Troy Balderson (R) 100 0

14 SB5 supporters could not survive a 5% swing from their margin of victory in 2010 (2 didn’t even reach the 50% threshold due to a third party taking significant support). With only a 10-seat margin to maintain control, it is quite possible that control of the Ohio House will swing away from the Republicans and back to the Democrats.

Such a swing, could put a halt to the Governors radical agenda and turn the remaining 2 years of his first term into a lame duck effort.

Will friends of David Brennan please stand up

The National Alliance for Public Charter Schools and the National Association of Charter School Authorizers, organizations whose agenda is to expand charter schools, co-wrote the following testimony against the Charter provisions that were secretly placed into the budget bill (HB153) by the House Republicans.

NACSA Letter opposing HB153 Charter ExpansionDoes David Brennan have no supporters in the charter school community?

Charter school amendments likely to be stripped

Credit where credit is due, the Governor's education Czar is also unhappy with the House Republican changes to the budget that creates a wild west charter school privatization system in Ohio.

House leaders refuse to say which legislator submitted the budget amendments. However, at least some were made at the request of major Republican donor and leading for-profit charter-school operator David L. Brennan, who runs White Hat Management in Akron.

Sommers told state board members today that school choice creates competition that will improve Ohio's education system. But both charter schools and traditional public schools alike must be accountable for student performance and public financing, and poorly performing schools must be shut down.

He also cited the need for "more transparency about funding for charter schools."

Clearly, pressure from all angles is causing some second thoughts, and hopfully the big loser in all this will be David Brennan and not pubic education and accountability.

White Hat Management Political Contributions

Plunderbund has an article detailing the failings of White Hat Management as a charter school management company, and in light of the news of the GOP plan to privatize public education, the political crosswinds that created the plan

The goal of this budget seems pretty obvious. White Hat has a problem with their schools and boards and sponsors so the legislature just removes them from the picture, allowing White Hat to drirectly start up schools as for-profit companies, eliminating the hassle of oversight. White Hat has a problem with people questioning how they use public funds provided by the state, so the legislature just makes those funds private as soon as they are delivered to White Hat.

Some of the language in this budget is so specifically directly at helping White Hat that it wouldn’t surprise me at all if Brennan’s lawyers write it themselves. Whether it’s true or not, Ohio’s GOP politicians appear to be paying back one of their largest campaign donors with millions of state dollars while completely disregarding the educational needs of thousands of Ohio’s students.

The whole article is worth a read.

Just to highlight the scope of Brennan's political largese, here is a list of the almost $1.6 million in political campaign contributions made by some of the main players involved with White Hat Management since 2000.

Cycle Amount Contributor Name Recipient Name
2010 $50,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L OHIO REPUBLICAN PARTY - EXECUTIVE CMTE
2010 $50,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L OHIO REPUBLICAN PARTY - EXECUTIVE CMTE
2010 $30,000 BRENNAN, ANN AMER OHIO REPUBLICAN PARTY - STATE CANDIDATE FUND
2010 $30,000 BRENNAN, ANN AMER OHIO REPUBLICAN PARTY - STATE CANDIDATE FUND
2010 $30,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L OHIO REPUBLICAN PARTY - STATE CANDIDATE FUND
2010 $25,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L OHIO REPUBLICAN PARTY - EXECUTIVE CMTE
2010 $25,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L OHIO REPUBLICAN PARTY - EXECUTIVE CMTE
2010 $17,075 BRENNAN, ANN AMER REPUBLICAN SENATE CAMPAIGN CMTE OF OHIO
2010 $17,075 BRENNAN, DAVID L REPUBLICAN SENATE CAMPAIGN CMTE OF OHIO
2010 $17,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L OHIO HOUSE REPUBLICAN CAMPAIGN CMTE
2010 $17,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L REPUBLICAN SENATE CAMPAIGN CMTE OF OHIO
2010 $17,000 BRENNAN, ANN AMER REPUBLICAN SENATE CAMPAIGN CMTE OF OHIO
2010 $17,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L OHIO HOUSE REPUBLICAN CAMPAIGN CMTE
2010 $11,396 BRENNAN, ANN AMER MANDEL, JOSH
2010 $11,396 BRENNAN, DAVID L KASICH, JOHN & TAYLOR, MARY
2010 $11,395 BRENNAN, DAVID L KASICH, JOHN & TAYLOR, MARY
2010 $11,395 BRENNAN, ANN AMER HUSTED, JON
2010 $11,395 BRENNAN, ANN AMER KASICH, JOHN & TAYLOR, MARY
2010 $11,350 BRENNAN, ANN AMER WAGONER, MARK
2010 $11,350 BRENNAN, DAVID L NIEHAUS, TOM
2010 $11,350 BRENNAN, ANN AMER FABER, KEITH
2010 $11,350 BRENNAN, ANN AMER NIEHAUS, TOM
2010 $11,300 BRENNAN, ANN AMER HUSTED, JON
2010 $11,300 BRENNAN, ANN AMER MANDEL, JOSH
2010 $11,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L DEWINE, MIKE
2010 $11,000 BRENNAN, ANN AMER MORGAN, SETH
2010 $11,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L BATCHELDER, WILLIAM G
2010 $11,000 BRENNAN, ANN AMER BATCHELDER, WILLIAM G
2010 $11,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L AMSTUTZ, RON
2010 $11,000 BRENNAN, ANN AMER HUFFMAN, MATT
2010 $11,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L BATCHELDER, WILLIAM G
2010 $11,000 BRENNAN, ANN AMER AMSTUTZ, RON
2010 $6,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L YOST, DAVID A
2010 $5,500 BRENNAN, DAVID L BACON, KEVIN
2010 $5,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L YOST, DAVID A
2010 $4,000 BRENNAN, ANN AMER OHIO REPUBLICAN PARTY - STATE CANDIDATE FUND
2010 $3,125 MANNA, ANTHONY OHIO REPUBLICAN PARTY - STATE CANDIDATE FUND
2010 $250 WEBER III, JOSEPH R MANDEL, JOSH
2010 $250 RICE, MARK A MANDEL, JOSH
2010 $250 MESSER JR, QUENTIN MANDEL, JOSH
2010 $250 WEBER III, JOSEPH R LAROSE, FRANK
2010 $100 MESSER JR, QUENTIN HUSTED, JON
2008 $100,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L OHIO REPUBLICAN PARTY - EXECUTIVE CMTE
2008 $100,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L OHIO REPUBLICAN PARTY - EXECUTIVE CMTE
2008 $100,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L OHIO REPUBLICAN PARTY - EXECUTIVE CMTE
2008 $100,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L OHIO REPUBLICAN PARTY - EXECUTIVE CMTE
2008 $50,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L OHIO REPUBLICAN PARTY - EXECUTIVE CMTE
2008 $50,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L OHIO REPUBLICAN PARTY - EXECUTIVE CMTE
2008 $30,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L OHIO REPUBLICAN PARTY - STATE CANDIDATE FUND
2008 $25,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L MR Republican National Cmte
2008 $16,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L REPUBLICAN SENATE CAMPAIGN CMTE OF OHIO
2008 $16,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L REPUBLICAN SENATE CAMPAIGN CMTE OF OHIO
2008 $16,000 BRENNAN, ANN AMER REPUBLICAN SENATE CAMPAIGN CMTE OF OHIO
2008 $16,000 BRENNAN, ANN AMER REPUBLICAN SENATE CAMPAIGN CMTE OF OHIO
2008 $15,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L OHIO HOUSE REPUBLICAN CAMPAIGN CMTE
2008 $12,500 BRENNAN, DAVID L OHIO HOUSE REPUBLICAN CAMPAIGN CMTE
2008 $10,650 BRENNAN, ANN AMER HARRIS, BILL
2008 $10,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L BACON, KEVIN
2008 $10,000 BRENNAN, ANN AMER TAYLOR, MARY
2008 $10,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L TAYLOR, MARY
2008 $10,000 BRENNAN, ANN AMER BATCHELDER, WILLIAM
2008 $10,000 BRENNAN, ANN AMER BATCHELDER, WILLIAM
2008 $10,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L BATCHELDER, WILLIAM
2008 $10,000 BRENNAN, ANN AMER COLEY, BILL
2008 $10,000 BRENNAN, ANN AMER DOLAN, MATTHEW
2008 $10,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L HOTTINGER, JAY
2008 $10,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L DOLAN, MATTHEW
2008 $10,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L HUSTED, JON
2008 $10,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L PATTON, THOMAS
2008 $10,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L NIEHAUS, TOM
2008 $10,000 BRENNAN, ANN AMER CAREY JR, JOHN A
2008 $10,000 BRENNAN, ANN AMER HUSTED, JON
2008 $10,000 BRENNAN, ANN AMER JONES, SHANNON
2008 $5,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L HITE, CLIFFORD
2008 $5,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L GINTER, TIM
2008 $5,000 BRENNAN, ANN AMER HOTTINGER, JAY
2008 $2,500 BRENNAN, DAVID L SCHLICHTER, JOHN
2008 $2,300 HARRISON, E D MS George V Voinovich (R)
2008 $2,300 BRENNAN, ANN Lamar Alexander (R)
2008 $2,300 BRENNAN, DAVID Lamar Alexander (R)
2008 $2,300 BRENNEN, NANCY J George V Voinovich (R)
2008 $2,300 BRENNAN, DAVID L James D Jordan (R)
2008 $1,300 BRENNAN, DAVID L George V Voinovich (R)
2008 $1,000 HARRISON, E D MS George V Voinovich (R)
2008 $1,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L George V Voinovich (R)
2008 $1,000 BRENNAN, ANN AMER TIFFANY, TOM
2008 $1,000 BRENNAN, ANN AMER DARLING, ALBERTA
2008 $1,000 BRENNAN, ANN AMER COUGHLIN, KEVIN
2008 $500 BRENNAN, ANN AMER EGELHOFF, JO
2008 $500 BRENNAN, ANN AMER HUSTED, JON
2008 $500 BRENNAN, ANN AMER DAVIS, BRETT
2008 $500 BRENNAN, ANN AMER PETROWSKI, JERRY J
2008 $500 BRENNAN, ANN AMER MURSAU, JEFFREY L
2008 $500 BRENNAN, ANN AMER NERISON, LEE
2008 $500 BRENNAN, ANN AMER HINES, J A
2008 $500 BRENNAN, ANN AMER HELLMAN, DAN
2008 $500 BRENNAN, ANN AMER NERISON, LEE
2008 $500 BRENNAN, ANN AMER HONADEL, MARK
2008 $500 BRENNAN, ANN AMER TOWNS, DEBI
2008 $500 BRENNAN, ANN AMER RIPP, KEITH
2008 $500 BRENNAN, ANN AMER VAN ROY, KARL
2008 $500 BRENNAN, ANN AMER FRISKE, DON
2008 $500 BRENNAN, ANN AMER MURTHA, JOHN
2008 $500 BRENNAN, ANN AMER WILLIAMS, MARY
2008 $500 BRENNAN, ANN AMER DOCKERY, PAULA
2008 $400 BRENNAN, ANN AMER HUEBSCH, MIKE
2008 $200 BRENNAN, DAVID L George V Voinovich (R)
2008 $200 BRENNAN, ANN AMER VOS, ROBIN J
2008 $200 BRENNAN, ANN AMER COLE, RANDY
2006 $15,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L REPUBLICAN SENATE CAMPAIGN CMTE OF OHIO
2006 $10,000 BRENNAN, ANN GREEN, MARK A (G)
2006 $10,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L CAREY JR, JOHN A
2006 $10,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L TAYLOR, MARY
2006 $10,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L HUSTED, JON
2006 $10,000 BRENNAN, DAVE GREEN, MARK A (G)
2006 $10,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L PETERSON, JON
2006 $10,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L HARTMANN, GREG
2006 $10,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L BRADLEY, JENNETTE B
2006 $10,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L LYNCH, DAVID
2006 $7,500 BRENNAN, DAVID L CAREY JR, JOHN A
2006 $5,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L TAYLOR, MARY
2006 $5,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L SEITZ, BILL
2006 $4,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L PETERSON, JON
2006 $2,500 BRENNAN, DAVID L LUTHER, BRANT
2006 $2,500 BRENNAN, DAVID L BACON, KEVIN
2006 $2,500 BRENNAN, DAVID L MARTIN, EARL J
2006 $2,500 BRENNAN, DAVID L STIVERS, STEVE
2006 $2,500 BRENNAN, DAVID L CATES, GARY
2006 $2,500 BRENNAN, DAVID L NIEHAUS, TOM
2006 $2,500 BRENNAN, DAVID L HOPPEL, JIM
2006 $2,500 BRENNAN, DAVID L STIVERS, STEVE
2006 $2,500 BRENNAN, DAVID L HAYES, WILLIAM C
2006 $2,100 BRENNAN, DAVID L Craig Foltin (R)
2006 $2,100 BRENNAN, DAVID L Craig Foltin (R)
2006 $2,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L PATTON, THOMAS F
2006 $2,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L MARTIN, EARL J
2006 $2,000 BRENNAN, DAVID L WEBSTER, SHAWN N
2004 $2,500 BRENNAN, DAVID L HAGAN, JOHN P
2004 $2,500 BRENNAN, DAVID L SETZER, ARLENE J
2004 $2,500 BRENNAN, DAVID L CALVERT, CHARLES E
2004 $2,500 BRENNAN, DAVID L NIEHAUS, TOM
2004 $2,500 BRENNAN, DAVID L CATES, GARY
2004 $2,500 BRENNAN, DAVID L PADGETT, JOY
2004 $2,500 BRENNAN, DAVID L PETRO, JIM
2004 $2,000 BRENNAN, NANCY J MRS George W Bush (R)
2004 $2,000 BRENNAN, ANN A MRS George W Bush (R)
2004 $1,000 BRENNAN, NANCY Steven C LaTourette (R)
2004 $1,000 BRENNAN, NANCY Mike DeWine (R)
2004 $1,000 BRENNAN, NANCY Bill McCollum (R)
2004 $1,000 KROHN, MARK E MR George W Bush (R)
2004 $1,000 MORRIS, JOHN C MR George W Bush (R)
2004 $1,000 BRENNAN, NANCY J George V Voinovich (R)
2004 $1,000 BRENNAN, NANCY J George V Voinovich (R)
2004 $500 BRENNAN, DAVID SPADY, FAWN
2002 $2,500 BRENNAN, DAVID L RAUSSEN, JAMES
2002 $2,500 BRENNAN, DAVID L RAUSSEN, JAMES
2002 $1,000 BRENNAN, NANCY J George V Voinovich (R)
2002 $1,000 BRENNAN, NANCY Mike DeWine (R)
2000 $1,500 BRENNAN, DAVID L GARDNER, RANDALL
2000 $1,000 BRENNAN, NANCY J George V Voinovich (R)

Data taken from www.transparencydata.com.

Charter Schools and Our Tax Dollars

Guest column, submitted by Jim Bauer.

Letter to the Editor:

Charter Schools and Our Tax Dollars

Charter schools must be monitored with scrutiny because of their use of public tax dollars. Since 2008, Ohio-based White Hat Management has used 230 million Ohio tax dollars in the creation of charter schools. They are funded by the State of Ohio based on the numbers of students they enroll. There is a growing role of the private management companies in publicly funded charter schools. These private charter management companies collect the money from the state and then distribute them to their affiliated charter schools. White Hat is the largest for-profit charter in Ohio with 15 affiliated charter schools, despite the fact that only 2 percent of its students are achieving the expected level as determined under federal education law. At the present time 10 of its own schools are suing, complaining that White Hat students are failing, and the company is refusing to account for how it has spent the money. They refuse to account for how much money they make as a profit.

Governor Kasich has been quoted time and time again that schools need to be run like a business. Akron businessman David L. Brennan (with his wife, Ann) established White Hat in 1998. A Columbus Dispatch article in December stated that David Brennan was one of the biggest contributors to Ohio political campaigns in the last 10 years. He was a contributor to Kasich’s campaign as well, certainly a strategic investment to ensure that more tax dollars are funneled his way. White Hat and Mr. Brennan now stand to make millions more as a result of Gov. Kasich’s announcement to remove the cap on the number of charter schools and his “parent trigger” plan where parents can choose to convert their failing public school into a charter school. To me this is nothing more than a corporate payback through our governor’s new policy.

I would assume members of the Tea Party would be upset that their tax dollars are given to “for-profit” schools that are performing at a level well below most public schools. After reading about White Hat --- is this a type of charter school that our governor has in mind? Charter schools must be evaluated and be responsible for every dollar spent. With millions of public tax dollars at stake, our governor and state legislature should demand that these operators be accountable for every expenditure, release a public record of their profits, and produce students performing at the expected level of success.

Jim Bauer